Car Buyers' Worst Mistakes

by Remar Sutton

How much money do you think educated car buyers can save over uneducated buyers when buying the same car? Would $5,000 get your attention?

Not long ago, I was involved in an undercover filming at a dealership where consumers paid that whopping difference on the same car. And the difference in the customers? One couple made the "big mistakes" outlined here; the other didn't. While you may not save this much money, you'll save a bunch if you avoid these classic car-buying errors.

1. Showing enthusiasm. If you act excited, the dealership sellers know they have a unique product you want. The price goes up instantly. You'll do well to keep that enthusiasm in check until you've driven home. Sneer a little if you like the car.
2. Buying in a hurry. If you buy on your first visit to a dealership, you don't have time to compare. If you say "yes" too fast, the price doesn't fall. Take your time. Be willing to walk away. The price at most dealerships falls quickly if you move slowly.
3. Giving deposits before the dealer approves your offer on a vehicle. Feel free to give a deposit, if you really want a vehicle. But don't give it until the boss has said "yes." Some dealerships use deposits to keep you there while they try to convince you to pay more profit. And you can't leave if they have your deposit -- money, a credit card, a driver's license, or your kids.
4. Being switched to leasing without doing your homework. Because dealerships make a much larger profit if they lease rather than sell you the same car, even the best dealership is going to try to "switch" you. They'll try to convince you leasing is cheaper than buying. It may be. But in most instances, it certainly isn't. If you want to lease, fine. Just don't do it on the spur of the moment.
5. Trading in your old car without knowing its value in advance. A dealership has the right to give you the least you will take for your old car. But you have a right to get the most your car is worth at that moment. To know that value, simply clean it up, and "shop" it -- try to sell it to several used car departments. The highest amount you're offered for it is your car's real value right now. Don't accept less than that in trade.
6. Financing automatically at the dealership. Dealerships may be the cheapest place to finance. To find out, simply bring a copy of the filled-out dealer contract to your credit union and compare contracts. If the dealership won't give you a copy, they're probably telling you they're not really the cheapest.

Big mistakes, big bucks out the window. We like to help you preserve your money -- that's what credit unions are all about. Avoid these mistakes, and put that money to work rather than throwing it away.

Editor's note: Remar Sutton's car-buying tips have been featured on "Good Morning America," "Today," "20/20," "Nightline," and in magazines such as People, Newsweek, and Credit Union Magazine. He's President of the national Consumer Task Force for Automotive Issues. He writes this column exclusively for credit union members.

© 2008 Progressions Credit Union

Phone 535.0191 • Toll-free 1.800.828.8691

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Volunteer Login